Should I buy a yacht? The pros and cons of owning a motorboat

Discover the intricate world of motor yacht ownership. Understand costs, benefits, potential income opportunities, and lifestyle impact of buying a boat.

05 February 2024

If you've landed on this page, it's likely that the idea of owning a motorboat has been playing on your mind. Perhaps the allure of sunsets at sea, thrilling rides on blue waters, or the promise of freedom and adventure have stirred up the question: Is buying a boat a good idea? We recognise that this is a significant decision, and it's crucial to thoroughly consider all aspects before plunging into such a commitment.

In this guide, we aim to navigate you through the intricacies of motor yacht ownership. We'll delve into the pros and cons of buying a boat, aiming to illuminate the grey areas and hopefully answer the myriad of questions that are likely swimming in your head. Things like, "Can I afford it?" "Is buying a boat a good investment?" "How will it change my lifestyle?" and ultimately, "Is buying a boat worth it?"

But first, let's start off with the very basics.

What is a motor yacht?

A motor yacht is a watercraft primarily driven by internal combustion engines. They offer a blend of comfort, luxury, and speed, perfect for those seeking fast-paced adventure or leisurely cruises. With sizes typically ranging from 30 to over 100 feet, they are spacious and designed with living quarters, making them suitable for extended vacations or potentially living on the water.

Unlike sailing boats, which harness wind power through sails, motor yachts rely on mechanical propulsion. This means they offer a greater degree of control and are not dependent on wind conditions. Consequently, operating a motor yacht often requires less sailing skill, allowing for an easier cruising experience. 

Types of motorboats

Motorboats come in various shapes and sizes, each meticulously designed to cater to a range of purposes. As you grapple with the decision of making a purchase, it's essential to ask yourself, 'Why buy a yacht? How do I plan to use it?' This is pivotal in steering your choices in the right direction. 

To help illuminate the expansive and varied world of motor yachts, we will classify them into four key categories: 

Motorboat size

  • Small motorboats: These include runabouts and dinghies, perfect for short, nearshore trips. 

  • Medium-sized motorboats: This category includes cabin cruisers and sports cruisers, offering more comfort for longer trips without reaching the size of a yacht. 

  • Large motorboats: This encompasses motor yachts and superyachts, luxurious vessels designed for extended cruising or living on the water. 

The vessel’s intended use 

  • Fishing boats: Specifically designed with fishing features such as rod holders, bait wells, and large open decks. 

  • Sports boats: Built for water skiing, wakeboarding, or other water sports, these boats are often fast and nimble. 

  • Pleasure boats: Designed for leisure activities like day cruising or yacht parties. 

  • Long-range cruisers: Larger vessels built for long sea voyages, often with extensive living accommodations. 

The design features of the motorboat 

  • Bowriders: Characterised by a seating area in the bow, these boats are great for day cruising. 

  • Centre consoles: Designed with the helm in the boat's centre, leaving an open deck for fishing or other activities. 

  • Walkarounds: These boats have a small cabin and a rail around the boat that allows you to walk from stern to bow with ease. 

  • Pontoon boats: Recognisable by their flat decks atop two or more pontoons, these are versatile and offer stability. 

The motor type 

  • Outboard motorboats: These crafts have a motor affixed to the outside of the boat, offering more space inside and ease of maintenance. 

  • Inboard motorboats: In these, the engine is built into the boat, providing better balance and higher top speed. 

  • Stern drive boats: Also known as inboard/outboards (I/Os), these have an engine inside the boat and a drive unit located outside the hull. 

Become an expert sailor with our newsletterSubscribe now

The pros and cons of buying a boat 

Similar to any significant investment, there are numerous pros and cons of buying a boat that deserve careful consideration. These must be judiciously balanced against your individual needs, lifestyle, and financial capacity. 

Why buying a motor yacht can be a good idea?

Here are eight compelling reasons that illuminate the benefits of owning a motor yacht: 

The upgrade: How yacht ownership enhances lifestyle

Owning a yacht can significantly upgrade your lifestyle. Imagine leisurely cruising the open waters, throwing lavish parties, or taking spontaneous weekend trips to secluded islands. This can provide an unprecedented level of luxury, freedom, and flexibility that few other possessions can match. 

Embracing speed and power with motor yachts

Motor yachts are renowned for their speed and power, enabling quick voyages and swift exploration. If your idea of boating includes covering vast distances in less time, a motorboat might be your ideal marine partner. 

The simplicity in navigating motorboats 

Motor yachts offer more straightforward operations than their sailing counterparts. Thanks to their mechanical propulsion systems, you can skip the learning curve associated with understanding wind patterns and mastering sailing techniques. 

Experiencing luxury comfort aboard motor yachts

Motor yachts are synonymous with comfort and luxury. With spacious interiors, modern amenities, and elegant living quarters, they deliver a top-tier experience that could make the sea feel like your second home.

Social and family connections aboard yachts

A yacht can be a perfect platform for creating unforgettable memories with family and friends. The shared experiences of sailing, exploring new locations, or simply enjoying each other's company in a unique setting can foster deeper connections.

Turning yachting luxury into profit

Buying a boat can be a good investment. When you're not using your motor yacht, it doesn't have to sit idle. Many owners charter their boats, transforming their luxury assets into income-generating ones.

Motorboat cruise itinerary flexibility

Motor yachts offer the freedom and flexibility to chart your course, regardless of the wind. This means you have greater control over your itinerary and can easily adjust your plans based on changing desires or weather conditions.

The freedom of adventure and exploration with motor yachts 

Owning a motor yacht means having a gateway to unlimited adventure. You have the liberty to explore secluded coves, visit remote islands, or embark on extended cruising expeditions whenever the sea calls.

Motor yachts: Your personal retreat for privacy and exclusivity

If your preference leans towards private, exclusive vacations away from crowded tourist spots, then a motor yacht can serve as your personal oasis. Enjoy peace and tranquillity on the open sea, with horizons all to yourself.

When buying a boat might be a bad idea

While owning a motor yacht can bring numerous benefits, there are also potential downsides to be aware of. Here are a few reasons why buying a motor yacht might not be the best choice for everyone:

If you’re not ready to make a significant initial investment

If you're not quite prepared for a considerable financial outlay, the initial cost of yacht ownership could be a deterrent. Luxury motorboats can be expensive; the bigger and more sophisticated the boat, the higher the price tag. On the bright side, several options exist to finance a motorboat!

If you're not willing to maintain a sufficient expense level 

Owning a yacht involves more than just the initial purchase price. Maintenance, motorboat insurance, docking fees, fuel, and potential crew salaries can add up, leading to substantial annual expenses that must be factored into your budget. However, it's worth noting that with thoughtful planning and management, there are several strategies to help keep these costs more manageable.

If you're looking to make a profitable investment

For those seeking assets that appreciate over time, buying a motor yacht might not be the right choice. Much like cars and other luxury items, motorboats typically depreciate. So, unless you own a rare or particularly sought-after model, you can expect your yacht to devalue over time.

Don’t get us wrong - there's still the potential to generate income throughout ownership. Consider the possibility of chartering out your yacht when you're not using it!

When time constraints overshadow leisure

A motor yacht requires a considerable amount of time and attention, from regular maintenance to navigation planning. If you are already stretched thin with responsibilities, adding a boat into the mix might be more stressful than it's worth. However, owning a sailboat could also serve as the perfect incentive to carve out more leisure time for yourself, friends, family, and loved ones.

If your lifestyle or location won't allow for a regular boat use 

Owning a motor yacht could seem excessive in certain geographical locations with distinctive seasons or among individuals with hectic lifestyles. This is especially true if the boat is used only occasionally throughout the year, casting doubts on whether the high ownership costs are justified.

If you hate surprises 

Those unprepared for the occasional unpredictability of marine craft might find yacht ownership daunting. Even with meticulous maintenance, unforeseen mechanical issues can emerge in motorboats, as in any vehicle, potentially leading to repair costs. But honestly, who wants a life without a sprinkle of surprise? Think of them as stories for your next dinner party!

Is buying a boat a good investment?

The question of whether buying a motor yacht is a good investment is not black and white. Instead, it depends significantly on various factors, including your financial situation, personal preferences, and how you plan to utilise the boat.

Is owning a yacht worth it: Financial considerations 

To start with, it's important to note that marine vessels, much like cars, typically depreciate over time. New boats can lose between 10-15% of their value in the first year. The upkeep, maintenance, insurance, and storage costs also tend to be high, which can add significantly to the overall expenses. Therefore, if you view this as a traditional financial investment and expect it to appreciate over time, buying a boat might be a waste of money for you.

The lifestyle investment when buying a boat 

Nevertheless, not all investments are about financial gain. If you view 'investment' in terms of lifestyle, experience, and personal enjoyment, the answer might be different. A motor yacht can provide a wealth of experiences that other acquisitions can't match. These could range from the simple joy of cruising at high speeds on a sunny day to the opportunity to explore secluded beaches, have ocean-side family reunions, or even take sabbatical journeys.

Potential motorboat income opportunities 

It's also worth noting that there are ways to offset some of the costs associated with boat ownership. For instance, some owners choose to charter their yachts when not in use, providing them with an income stream that can help cover costs. However, this comes with its own set of challenges and responsibilities, including increased wear and tear on the boat, managing operations, or dealing with a charter company.

The pros and cons of buying a new boat vs a used one 

Opting for a used boat is an alternative that can notably reduce your initial investment and alleviate the impact of depreciation. A well-maintained pre-owned vessel can offer the same benefits and luxuries as a brand-new one but at a markedly reduced price. Yet, with a new motor yacht, you get the latest design and technology, not to mention the allure of being the first to navigate it through the waters.

In the table below, we provide a detailed comparison of the pros and cons associated with buying a new boat versus a used one:

 

Category

New boat

Used boat

Price

High initial cost

Lower initial cost

Depreciation

Rapid depreciation in the first few years

Slower depreciation as major depreciation has already occurred

Condition

Pristine and untouched, no history of wear or damage

Condition depends on previous usage and maintenance, potential for hidden damage or issues

Technology

Latest technology and design, potential for customisation

Likely older technology and design

Warranty

New manufacturer warranty

May have remaining transferable warranty, or none at all

Insurance

Typically higher due to greater value

Usually lower, reflecting the lower market value

Delivery Time

Might need to wait for build and delivery

Immediate availability as it's already built

Should I buy a yacht? The bottom line 

As we've traversed through the sea of considerations, it's evident that the pros and cons of buying a motorboat can be viewed from multiple angles and will significantly depend on individual circumstances.

Unless your aim is to establish a charter company or a similar business, buying a boat purely for monetary return may be a bad investment. However, viewed from other perspectives, it could yield significant gains. Beyond the allure of luxury and adventure, motor yacht ownership may confer substantial mental health benefits such as stress alleviation, enhanced relaxation, and an unparalleled sense of freedom. Furthermore, it paves the way for a community of fellow enthusiasts, enriching your social sphere.

Ultimately, your decision rests on your individual lifestyle, financial preparedness, and your vision of life on the water. Remember, your nearest local dealer is an excellent source of counsel and further deliberation on whether boat ownership is the right wave for you to ride.

Receive advice tailored to your boating needsFind a motorboat dealer
Frequently Asked Questions

Share this article